Malaria in Pregnancy: An Unrecognized Risk Factor for Neuropsychiatric Disease in Offspring?

Vanessa Tran, Andrea Weckman and Kevin C. Kain*


DOI10.21767/2573-0282.100016
Vanessa Tran1*, Andrea Weckman1,2 and Kevin C. Kain1,2,3*

1Sandra A. Rotman Laboratories, Sandra Rotman Centre for Global Health, Toronto General Research Institute-University Health Network,
Toronto, Ontario, Canada

2Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

3Department of Medicine, Tropical Disease Unit, Division of Infectious Diseases, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

*Corresponding Author:
Kevin C. Kain
Department of Medicine
Tropical Disease Unit
Division of Infectious Diseases
University of Toronto,
Toronto, Ontario
Canada
Email: kevin.kain@uhn.ca

Received date: May 28, 2016; Accepted date: June 10, 2016; Published date: June 13, 2016

Citation: Kain KC, Weckman A and Tran V (2016) Malaria in Pregnancy: An Unrecognized Risk Factor for Neuropsychiatric Disease in Offspring? Pediatric Infect Dis 1:16. doi: 10.21767/2573-0282.100016

Visit for more related articles at Pediatric Infectious Diseases: Open Access

Abstract

The in vitro environment has a profound effect on offspring neurodevelopment. Insults to the foetus during pregnancy can disrupt neurodevelopmental processes culminating in neurochemical and behavioural abnormalities. A growing body of evidence supports a role for maternal infection in precipitating neuropsychiatric disease in offspring. Since ~60% of pregnancies globally are at risk of malaria infection annually, we hypothesize that in utero exposure to malaria in pregnancy (MIP) may be a neglected risk factor for mental illness. We propose that the host response to infection makes an important contribution to this risk. MIP may mediate neuropathology via immune activation and inflammation in the placenta and consequent dysregulation of processes critical to fetal neurodevelopment including cerebral angiogenesis, neurogenesis, synaptic pruning, and neurochemical regulation.

Keywords

Malaria, Pregnancy, Maternal infection, Neuropsychiatric disease

Abbreviations

ASD: Autism Spectrum Disorder; BD: Bipolar Disorder; DALY: Disability-Adjusted Life Years; FGR: Fetal Growth Restriction; LBW: Low Birth Weight; VLBW: Very Low Birth Weight; MIP: Malaria In Pregnancy; PM: Placental Malaria; Poly(I:C): Polyriboinosinic-Polyribocytidilic acid; PTB: Preterm Birth; SGA: Small For Gestational Age

The Global Burden of Mental Illness

Neuropsychiatric disease is an enormous contributor to the global financial and social burden of health. According to a 2015 meta-analysis, an estimated 8 million deaths, representing 14.3% of global mortality, can be attributed to neuropsychiatric disease [1]. Even more importantly, neuropsychiatric disease is the leading cause of disabilityadjusted life years (DALYs) worldwide, with 96 million DALYs attributed to schizophrenia, depression, and bipolar disorder (BD) alone [2]. The financial cost of mental illness in low- and middle-income countries in 2010 was estimated at $870 billion USD and this number is expected to double by 2030 [2]. The majority of this cost is allocated to treatment. To reduce this staggering burden, resources and interventions that focus on prevention of neuropsychiatric disease would likely have more impact and reduce the long-term costs. Mounting pre-clinical and epidemiological evidence has implicated maternal infection as a risk factor for developing neuropsychiatric diseases including autism spectrum disorder (ASD), schizophrenia, BD, and depression [3].

Notably, low and middle income countries, including most sub-Saharan African countries, have a disproportionately high burden of mental illness, which has often been attributed to a number of social determinants and a lack of effective treatments and health care professionals, such as psychiatrists [4]. While these social factors likely contribute, maternal infection may represent an important and underappreciated risk factor. Given the high prevalence of malaria in these regions, we propose that the disproportionate burden of mental illness in low and middle income countries may also be associated with MIP and hypothesize that prenatal malaria exposure is a modifiable risk factor for neuropsychiatric disorders later in life (Figure 1). MIP has an established role in adverse birth outcomes including low birth weight (LBW) and stillbirth. Re-thinking MIP as a preventable risk factor for childhood neurocognitive and adult neuropsychiatric disorders has profound global health implications and could galvanize efforts to prevent maternal infections. Here, we review the evidence for the maternal infection hypothesis of psychiatric disease and examine the potential for MIP to contribute to the global burden of neuropsychiatric disorders.

pediatric-infectious-disease-burden-of-mental-illness

Figure 1: The burden of mental illness overlaps with areas of high malaria endemicity. The global burden of malaria is represented as total population at risk in both low and high transmission areas (adapted from Global Malaria Mapper, 2015). Low resource regions have a disproportionately high number of at-risk pregnancies and experience a high burden of neuropsychiatric disorders (measured in daily adjusted life years (DALYs)). a[5]; b[75].

Adverse Birth Outcomes in Placental Malaria

Approximately 125 million pregnant women are at risk of MIP each year and over 85 million of these occur in areas with stable Plasmodium falciparum transmission [5]. MIP can result in placental malaria (PM), which is characterized by the accumulation of malaria-infected erythrocytes and monocytes in the placenta. PM can have negative health consequences for mother and child, including maternal anaemia, stillbirth, and LBW caused by preterm birth (PTB) and/or fetal growth restriction (FGR) [6]. PM-mediated morbidity and mortality is influenced by parity, maternal immune status, stage of pregnancy at infection, and chronicity of infection [7,8].

These adverse birth outcomes are thought to result, at least in part, from increased inflammation at the maternal-fetal interface. Sequestration of parasitized erythrocytes in the intervillous space of the placenta triggers the secretion of chemotactic β-chemokines by mononuclear cells, resulting in an accumulation of monocytes and macrophages, and a deviation from the normal cytokine profile in the placenta [9,10]. For example, pro-inflammatory cytokines such as TNF are increased in PM and have been associated with poor birth outcomes [9,11].

A central initiator and enhancer of the localized inflammatory response in PM is complement. The complement system is an essential component of innate immunity and the host defence against pathogens. However, dysregulated activation or control of the complement system is associated with several adverse pregnancy outcomes, such as preeclampsia and spontaneous abortion [12,13]. Human, pre-clinical models, and in vitro studies have shown that PM is associated with increased activation of the complement system, in particular enhanced generation of the proinflammatory component C5a [14,15]. In vitro, C5a can induce the synergistic release of both inflammatory mediators (e.g. TNF, IL-6, IL-8, MCP-1) and anti-angiogenic factors (e.g. sFlt-1) from human mononuclear cells [15]. Moreover in pre-clinical and clinical studies increased levels of C5a were associated with dysregulation of angiogenic factors (e.g. VEGF, endoglin, angiopoietin-1 and angiopoietin-2), placental vascular insufficiency, and an increased risk of adverse birth outcomes including LBW and stillbirth [14,15].

PM-mediated LBW has a marked impact on neonatal mortality and is estimated to contribute to 200,000 infant deaths per year [16]. Even for those babies that survive the neonatal period, however, numerous epidemiological and animal studies have linked LBW with long-term neurodevelopmental deficits and adult disease (Figure 2).

pediatric-infectious-disease-proposed-pathways

Figure 2: The proposed pathways through which maternal infection including PM could precipitate neuropsychiatric injury. Bacterial, viral, and parasitic infections during pregnancy induce pathological inflammation at the maternal-fetal interface. (a) LBW-dependent phenotypes. MIP-mediated inflammation in the placenta leads to dysregulated angiogenesis and placental insufficiency, resulting in adverse birth outcomes including low birth weight (LBW). LBW infants are known to be at higher risk for cognitive deficits, psychiatric outcomes (ASD, BD, and schizophrenia), and chronic diseases in adulthood (cardiovascular disease (CVD), diabetes, and hypertension). (b) LBW-independent phenotypes. Fetal exposure to maternal immune activation can result in alterations in brain vasculature, neurochemical and other neurophysiological processes critical to neurodevelopment. These changes correlate with neurocognitive deficits and altered behaviour in childhood and adults. Similar to other maternal infections, exposure to malaria in utero may also prime the offspring for development of psychiatric disorders in response to a second environmental “hit” later in life.

The Impact of Low Birth Weight on Neurodevelopment

Over 20 million babies are born LBW each year, the majority of which are in low resource countries [17]. LBW can occur from either PTB and/or being small for gestational age (SGA). PTB is the leading cause of childhood mortality worldwide, accounting for over one million deaths [18,19]. Further, LBW from PTB is associated with greater mortality and more severe outcomes, such as cerebral palsy, than LBW caused by SGA. The etiology of PTB and SGA varies by region and is multifactorial including tobacco and drug use during pregnancy, malnutrition, maternal infection, hypertension, and preeclampsia [20,21]. Both PTB and SGA have been linked to significant neonatal morbidity and long-term adverse health outcomes.

Numerous epidemiological studies have identified an association between restricted fetal growth with poor growth in childhood and a higher incidence of chronic diseases in adulthood. This correlation between LBW and adult disease is known as the “Barker Hypothesis” of developmental plasticity and programming [22,23]. Adult chronic diseases associated with this phenomenon include obesity, coronary artery disease, hypertension, and type 2 diabetes [22]. LBW has also been associated with impaired neurodevelopment leading to cognitive and behavioural deficits in childhood and adolescence. For example, a meta-analysis of case-control studies of PTB children found that decreasing birth weight and decreasing mean gestational age at birth correlated with lower cognitive test scores. Further, children born preterm and very LBW (VLBW) (< 1500g) were twice as likely to develop attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and exhibit autism-like symptoms [24,25]. In another study, very preterm (≤ 33 weeks gestation) and VLBW infants had significant deficits in academic achievement, including mathematics and reading performance, and poor executive function compared to their full term, normal birth weight peers [26]. These learning and behavioural impairments impact school performance and can persist to adulthood.

In addition to deficits in cognition and learning, epidemiological studies have associated LBW with an increased risk for neuropsychiatric and affective disorders later in life. For example, a Norwegian study examined psychiatric outcomes in adolescents born preterm and VLBW and reported that LBW was associated with reduced psychosocial function and an increase in ADHD symptoms [27]. Similar to other epidemiological studies, these findings were significant after adjusting for confounding factors, including maternal mental illness, gender, and social economic status. Further, population-based studies indicate that these deficits can persist into adulthood. The Helsinki Study of Very Low Birth Weight Adults found that adults who were born preterm and VLBW had an increased risk of ASD, represented by a higher social interaction sum score and a lower attention to detail score [28]. Findings from these epidemiological studies have been supported by animal models, where rodent models of FGR using maternal food restriction showed heightened anxiety-like behaviour in offspring that were LBW [29,30].

It is clear that PM-mediated LBW has both short- and longterm negative health consequences. However, most malaria in pregnancy result in normal birth weight infants, but whether these babies have neurocognitive and behavioural deficits is unknown. However accumulating evidence supports the hypothesis that even pauci-symptomatic maternal infections may represent an environmental “hit” that may precipitate or predispose offspring to neuropsychiatric disorders later in life [3].

Maternal Infection and Impact on Neurodevelopment

Numerous factors contribute to the development of neuropsychiatric disorders, including genetic risk alleles, epigenetic changes, and environmental triggers. In addition to these, a growing body of epidemiological and pre-clinical evidence supports a link between prenatal exposure to maternal viral and bacterial infections, and several neuropsychiatric disorders including schizophrenia, ASD, and BD [3,3134]. The first association between maternal infection and an increased risk for psychotic disorders came from the observation of a seasonal pattern in birth dates among patients with schizophrenia and BD [3537]. Consistently, epidemiological studies found that adults born during an influenza epidemic had an increased risk of schizophrenia [35,38]. More rigorous prospective studies using serologic detection of prenatal influenza infection further supported this link [39]. Clinical evidence of fetal exposure to maternal infections with Toxoplasma gondii and herpes simplex virus (type II) and an increased risk of adult schizophrenia have also been found [4042]. Evidence from large birth cohorts have emerged that further support an association between maternal infection and an increased risk for other neuropsychiatric disorders including BD, ASD, and posttraumatic stress disorder [3,32,4345].

Ethical and logistical considerations limit the ability to examine causality in human epidemiological studies. Therefore, the use of animal models has enabled mechanistic and causal studies of maternal infection inducing neuropsychiatric disorders. These animal studies have supported and extended the findings from human populationbased epidemiological studies. These models have exploited the use of whole virus (influenza), the viral mimic polyriboinosinic-polyribocytidilic acid (poly (I:C)), and bacterial endotoxin lipopolysaccharide (LPS), to trigger systemic maternal immune activation [33,46]. In addition to these models of systemic maternal infection in pregnancy, turpentine intramuscular administration has been used to model local maternal inflammation, which has enabled the exploration of maternal versus fetal contributions to neurobehavioral outcomes [47]. Importantly, animal models permit control of confounding factors and have enabled the study of single infectious agents and/or inflammatory factors as well as the contribution of genetic risk and environmental factors in precipitating neuropsychiatric outcomes.

Mechanisms of Impaired Neurodevelopment Following in Utero Exposure to Infection

Evidence from human and animal studies support the hypothesis that maternal immune activation in response to infection underlies the persistent immunological and neurological alterations in the offspring that contribute to neuropsychiatric outcomes. Neurodevelopment is a complex and tightly regulated process that requires multiple orchestrated steps to achieve functional neural networks and the refinement of the central nervous system (CNS) required for specific connectivity and neurotransmission. Multiple lines of evidence support a critical non-immune role for the complement system and cytokines in both normal and abnormal neurodevelopmental processes (i.e. synaptic pruning, synaptic refinement, regulation of neural stem cell pools, neurodegenerative diseases) [13,48,49]. Maternal inflammation at the placental-fetal interface can induce an inflammatory response in the foetus. Several cytokines, including IL-6, are able to cross the placenta and fetal bloodbrain barrier [50], placing the developing foetus at risk of an imbalance of critical neurodevelopmental factors. IL-6 is frequently induced during prenatal infections and has been detected at elevated levels in maternal serum, placenta, and fetal brain in the poly (I:C) model of maternal infection [51]. Mechanistically, IL-6 is critically involved in the regulation of neural stem cell pools and neurogenesis [48], and elevated levels can contribute to aberrations in these developmental processes, resulting in long term neurological deficits [51]. This contention is supported by the findings that functional blockade (e.g. anti-IL-6 antibody) or genetic disruption of IL-6, in poly (I:C)-treated dams prevented behavioural deficits in the exposed offspring [51]. Other pro-inflammatory cytokines or factors that have been implicated in abnormal neurodevelopment include TNF, IL-8/CXCL8, IL-1β, and CRP [5254]. The use of single cytokine-induced systemic inflammation has helped to define their specific roles in the maternal infection model of neuropsychiatric disease. For example, a single IL-6 injection in pregnant mice elicited behavioural phenotypes in the offspring similar to the poly(I:C) or LPS models [51]. Inflammation at the fetal-maternal interface has also been reported to damage the blood-brain barrier leading to pathological neuro-inflammation, neuronal cell death, and white matter injury [55]. Other immunological mediators have also been implicated in the aberrant neurodevelopment resulting from maternal immune activation. Specifically, synaptic pruning and refinement, processes that are crucial for normal brain function, are known to require the complement protein C1q and MHC class 1 [5658]. Altered levels of these proteins have been associated with abnormal neuronal connectivity, disturbances in neurotransmitter systems, and abnormal behaviour. Maternal infection is also associated with hypomyelination in offspring, leading to abnormal brain white matter, as well as impaired neuronal migration due to reduced reelin expression, a key regulator of neuronal migration in the CNS [59,60]. A recent study reported that maternal malaria infection was associated with decreased levels of brain-derived neurotropic factor (BDNF) a critical regulator of neuron growth and remodelling, synapse formation, and neurotransmitter release [61,62]. Decreased BDNF was associated with a subsequent decrease in regional neurotransmitter levels that correlated with neurocognitive and behavioural deficits in offspring [63].

Early perturbations to CNS development would be expected to promote long-term alterations in neurophysiology and subsequent behaviour. Consistent with this model, patients with ASD and schizophrenia often exhibit abnormal immunology, including increased levels of IL-6 and TNF in circulation and in cerebrospinal fluid, in adulthood [64,65]. This phenomenon is hypothesized to occur through microglia priming. Microglia is CNS resident macrophages that act as primary immune mediators. Maternal immune activation with poly (I:C) or LPS results in persistent microglia alterations in the offspring that can be hyper-reactive to subsequent stimuli [53,66]. This observation aligns with the “two-hit” hypothesis of neuropsychiatric disease, which posits that early neurodevelopmental interference such as maternal infection primes the offspring for neuropsychiatric disorders in response to a “second hit" (i.e. stress, infection, trauma, drugs) later in life [67]. Accordingly in pre-clinical models a secondary insult, such as peripubertal stress or postnatal poly (I:C) challenge, following prenatal exposure to an immune stimulus resulted in hyperactive microglia, intensified inflammatory response, and schizophrenia-like behaviour [68,69].

Malaria in Pregnancy and Neurocognitive Outcomes

Given the mounting evidence to support the link between in vitro exposure to maternal infections and an increased risk for neuropsychiatric disorders, we hypothesize that MIP can also prime the offspring for detrimental neurological outcomes. Recent evidence indicates that mice exposed to malaria in vitro exhibit neurological injury and importantly, this occurs in the absence of LBW or other birth phenotype. Malariaexposed, pre-pubescent mice displayed increased depressivelike behaviour and deficits in learning and memory [63]. These behavioural and cognitive deficits correlated with abnormal fetal brain vasculature, decreased BDNF expression and reduced regional neurotransmitter levels of dopamine, serotonin and norepinephrine. CNS angiogenesis and neurogenesis are co-regulated and abnormal neurovasculature development could contribute to altered neurogenesis and lasting neurological injury in offspring. Importantly, the PMexposed mice were not congenitally infected, consistent with the idea that the host response to the pathogen, rather than the pathogen itself, plays a major role in driving the observed adverse fetal outcomes. Further, disruption of C5a-C5aR signalling rescued neurocognitive deficits and restored neurochemical balance in the exposed offspring [63]. Given the central role of C5a in inflammation, and the importance of brain vascularization in normal neurodevelopment, it is reasonable to hypothesize that these immune mechanisms of injury could also contribute to neuropsychiatric disorders.

The neurochemical changes in malaria-exposed offspring are consistent with reports of altered brain chemistry in neuropsychiatric disorders [62,70,71]. In further support of this hypothesis, several inflammatory factors including IL-6, TNF and CRP that are implicated as mediators of maternal immune activation-related neuropsychiatric disorders [51,53,54,72] are increased in MIP [9,15,73,74].

Concluding Remarks

Maternal infection and its impact on the in vitro environment, represents a paradigm shift in our understanding of the risk factors and putative mechanisms underlying neurocognitive and neuropsychiatric disorders and suggest that MIP may be a potential and preventable risk factor. Collectively the emerging evidence defining links between maternal infection and neuropsychiatric disorders in offspring has important implications for the cause and prevention of what were previously believed to be non-communicable diseases, and may shift global health priorities from costly lifelong treatment and rehabilitation to prevention. It has been estimated that prevention of viral, bacterial, and parasitic infections during pregnancy could prevent more than 30% of schizophrenia cases [35]. Factors that contribute to neurological injury in infants place enormous social and financial burdens on families and communities, especially in low-resource settings. In the case of MIP, neurological injury can occur via both LBW and LBW-independent pathways (Figure 2). Similar to Zika infection in pregnancy, the nature of this injury may depend on the timing of infection since the stages of fetal neurodevelopment correlate with different stages of gestation [3]. For example, malaria infection during the first trimester could more profoundly impact neurogenesis, whereas infection later in gestation may disrupt neuronal migration or myelination. Whether this timing might cause differing neuropsychiatric outcomes is unknown [3]. Clearly additional prospective and mechanistic studies are required to determine and define the potential risk of MIP in human populations. However, given the high prevalence of malaria in many low-resource settings, ultimately, targeting MIP may represent a cost-effective strategy for the concurrent reduction of maternal and childhood morbidity and mortality, as well as juvenile and adult mental illness.

Funding

This review was supported in part by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research [CIHR MOP- 136813 and MOP-115160 to KCK]; Canadian Research Chair (KCK); Global Alliance to Prevent Prematurity and Stillbirth and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Grand Challenges in Global Health: Preventing Preterm Birth Initiative Grant No. 12003 [KCK]. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

References

open access journals, open access scientific research publisher, open access publisher
Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language

Viewing options

Flyer image

Share This Article

paper.io

agar io

wowcappadocia.com
cappadocia-hotels.com
caruscappadocia.com
brothersballoon.com
balloon-rides.net

wormax io